6d:{"facet_counts":[{"counts":[{"count":17,"highlighted":"decision","value":"decision"},{"count":1,"highlighted":"rechtssatz","value":"rechtssatz"}],"field_name":"documentType","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":2}},{"counts":[{"count":14,"highlighted":"BVwG","value":"BVwG"},{"count":4,"highlighted":"VwGH","value":"VwGH"}],"field_name":"institution","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":2}},{"counts":[],"field_name":"lawType","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":0}},{"counts":[],"field_name":"jurisdiction","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":0}},{"counts":[{"count":1,"highlighted":"Wirtschaftsrecht","value":"Wirtschaftsrecht"}],"field_name":"legalCategories","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":1}},{"counts":[],"field_name":"state","sampled":false,"stats":{"total_values":0}}],"found":18,"found_docs":18,"grouped_hits":[{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20251031_w156_2315682_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2315682-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1768262400000,"citation":"W156 2315682-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1761868800000,"documentType":"decision","facts":"Eine vietnamesische Staatsangehörige beantragte am 21.01.2025 die Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte als Fachkraft im Mangelberuf Koch gemäß § 12a AuslBG. Der Antrag wurde abgelehnt, da die erforderliche Mindestpunktzahl von 55 Punkten nicht erreicht wurde. Die Antragstellerin legte ein Ausbildungszeugnis aus Vietnam und ein Sprachzertifikat Deutsch A2 vor, konnte jedoch keine ausreichenden Nachweise für eine vergleichbare Berufsausbildung oder Berufserfahrung erbringen. Zudem fehlte die kollektivvertragliche Einstufung im Dienstvertrag. Die Berufserfahrung in der Slowakei konnte nicht durch Sozialversicherungsnachweise belegt werden. Die Beschwerde gegen die Ablehnung wurde abgewiesen, da die Voraussetzungen für die Erteilung der Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte nicht erfüllt waren. Eine mündliche Verhandlung wurde als nicht erforderlich erachtet. Die Revision wurde als unzulässig erklärt, da keine erhebliche Rechtsfrage vorliegt.","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20251031_w156_2315682_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalAssessment":"$7f","legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20251031_w156_2315682_1_00","publishedDate":1768262400000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2315682-1","citation":"W156 2315682-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20251031_w156_2315682_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20251031_w156_2315682_1_00","value":"W156 2315682-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.187.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"NAG","citation":"NAG","clauseId":"NOR40272190","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"20004242","lawType":"BG","normId":"20004242","value":"NAG "},{"abbreviation":"GSVG","citation":"§ 2 Abs. 1 Z 4 GSVG","clauseId":"NOR40264392","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 2","id":"10008422.5.1.0.3","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008422","value":"§ 2 Abs. 1 Z4 GSVG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG "},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 4 Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40272196","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 4","id":"10008365.4.1.0.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 4 Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 4 Abs. 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40272196","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 4","id":"10008365.4.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 4 Abs. 1 Z 3, 4, 5 und 6 AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016937","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000308.6","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000308","value":"Art. 6 EMRK"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2315682-1/7E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra Krebitz als Vorsitzende und die fachkundigen Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde der XXXX , vertreten durch Hofbauer Wagner Rechtsanwälte K…","source":"ris","title":"Abweisung der Beschwerde gegen die Ablehnung der Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte für eine vietnamesische Fachkraft im Mangelberuf Koch","verdict":"Die Beschwerde wird als unbegründet abgewiesen. Die Revision ist nicht zulässig.","version":2,"caseNumber":"W156 2315682-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Wie bereits beweiswürdigend festgestellt wurde, konnte mit dem im Verfahren vorgelegten Ausbildungsunterlagen keine einschlägige abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung, die mit der österreichischen Lehre zum Koch/Köchin, vergleichbar"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Wie bereits beweiswürdigend festgestellt wurde, konnte mit dem im Verfahren vorgelegten Ausbildungsunterlagen keine einschlägige abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung, die mit der österreichischen Lehre zum Koch/Köchin, vergleichbar"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.75},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":13,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927338","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20241003_w156_2297377_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2297377-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1730073600000,"citation":"W156 2297377-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1727913600000,"documentType":"decision","facts":"Ein Antragsteller aus China beantragte eine Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte als Fachkraft in Mangelberufen für die Position 'Economist – Clean Energy' in einem Wiener Unternehmen. Der Antrag wurde abgelehnt, da die erforderliche Mindestpunkteanzahl von 55 Punkten gemäß Anlage B des Ausländerbeschäftigungsgesetzes (AuslBG) nicht erreicht wurde. Der Antragsteller erhielt Punkte für Qualifikation, Alter und Berufserfahrung, jedoch nicht für Sprachkenntnisse, da kein gültiges Sprachzertifikat nach dem Gemeinsamen Europäischen Referenzrahmen vorgelegt wurde. Die Beschwerdeführerin argumentierte, dass Englisch als Unternehmenssprache 5 Zusatzpunkte rechtfertige, was jedoch abgelehnt wurde, da reguläre Punkte für Englisch mangels gültigen Nachweises nicht vergeben werden konnten. Eine mündliche Verhandlung wurde als nicht erforderlich angesehen, da der Sachverhalt aus der Aktenlage hervorging. Die Revision wurde als unzulässig erklärt, da keine erhebliche Rechtsfrage vorlag.","hasSummary":true,"id":"bvwgt_20241003_w156_2297377_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte","Fachkraft in Mangelberufen","Mindestpunkteanzahl","Sprachkenntnisse","Unzulässigkeit der Revision"],"legalAssessment":"$80","legalCategories":["Wirtschaftsrecht"],"normId":"bvwgt_20241003_w156_2297377_1_00","publishedDate":1730073600000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2297377-1","citation":"W156 2297377-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20241003_w156_2297377_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20241003_w156_2297377_1_00","value":"W156 2297377-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"NAG-DV","citation":"§ 9 NAG-DV","clauseId":"NOR40246949","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 9","id":"20004470.11","lawType":"V","normId":"20004470","value":"§ 9 NAG-DV"},{"abbreviation":"NAG-DV","citation":"NAG-DV","clauseId":"NOR40253942","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"20004470","lawType":"V","normId":"20004470","value":"NAG-DV "},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"NAG","citation":"NAG","clauseId":"NOR40205333","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"20004242","lawType":"BG","normId":"20004242","value":"NAG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"NAG","citation":"§ 21a NAG","clauseId":"NOR40205360","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 21a","id":"20004242.19","lawType":"BG","normId":"20004242","value":"§ 21a NAG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 6 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40245607","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.31.7","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 6 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbrNr":2,"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016955","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000309.6.0","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000309","value":"Art 6 Abs. 1 EMRK"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2297377-1/3E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra KREBITZ als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde der XXXX in XXXX Wien (Beschwerdeführerin), gegen den B…","source":"ris","title":"Abweisung der Beschwerde gegen die Ablehnung einer Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte für Fachkräfte in Mangelberufen","verdict":"Die Beschwerde wird als unbegründet abgewiesen und die Beschwerdevorentscheidung bestätigt. Die Revision ist nicht zulässig.","caseNumber":"W156 2297377-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Der Mitbeteiligte weist eine abgeschlossene Ausbildung als Bachelor of Economics nach und ist somit die Ausbildung unter das Berufsbild „Sozial-, Wirtschaftswissenschafter/innen, wissenschaftliche Statistiker"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Der Mitbeteiligte weist eine abgeschlossene Ausbildung als Bachelor of Economics nach und ist somit die Ausbildung unter das Berufsbild „Sozial-, Wirtschaftswissenschafter/innen, wissenschaftliche Statistiker"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.625},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927322","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0},"vector_distance":0.8354290723800659}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["jwr_2025090055_20251020l01"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/09/0055","Rechtssatznummer":"1","apiPath":["Vwgh"],"changedDate":1767830400000,"citation":"Ra 2025/09/0055","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1760918400000,"documentType":"rechtssatz","hasSummary":false,"id":"jwr_2025090055_20251020l01","institution":["VwGH"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Auslegung Anwendung der Auslegungsmethoden Verhältnis der wörtlichen Auslegung zur teleologischen und historischen Auslegung Bedeutung der Gesetzesmaterialien VwRallg3/2/2"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"jwr_2025090055_20251020l01","publishedDate":1764028800000,"refs":[{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l03","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"}],"snippet":"Der VwGH hat unter Zugrundelegung der Materialien zur Novellierung des § 12a AuslBG durch BGBl. I Nr. 25/2011 (ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24. GP 12) bereits festgehalten, dass der Gesetzgeber als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine verg…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"Ra 2025/09/0055"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"vergleichbar ist oder dem Abschluss einer berufsbildenden höheren Schule in Österreich entspricht (VwGH 22.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0059; VwGH 25.1.2013, 2012/09/0068; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Ergänzend ist auf Folgendes hinzuweisen: Nach § 34a Abs. 1 Berufsausbildungsgesetz gilt (u.a.) für den Bereich der beruflichen Qualifikationen nicht nur das Prüfungszeugnis einer berufsbildenden"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"vergleichbar ist oder dem Abschluss einer berufsbildenden höheren Schule in Österreich entspricht (VwGH 22.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0059; VwGH 25.1.2013, 2012/09/0068; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Ergänzend ist auf Folgendes hinzuweisen: Nach § 34a Abs. 1 Berufsausbildungsgesetz gilt (u.a.) für den Bereich der beruflichen Qualifikationen nicht nur das Prüfungszeugnis einer berufsbildenden"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.375},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927322","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20241029_w167_2293590_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2293590-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1731888000000,"citation":"W167 2293590-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1730160000000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20241029_w167_2293590_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20241029_w167_2293590_1_00","publishedDate":1731888000000,"refs":[{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"GewO 1994","citation":"GewO 1994","clauseId":"NOR11007641","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10007517","lawType":"BG","normId":"10007517","value":"GewO 1994 "},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40245607","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.31.1.0.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W167 2293590-1/11E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela ECKERSDORFER und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Beschwerde von XXXX (B…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2293590-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer hat die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer hat die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.375},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0},"vector_distance":0.8388093709945679}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250128_w156_2301381_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2301381-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1740700800000,"citation":"W156 2301381-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1738022400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250128_w156_2301381_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Fachkräfteverordnung Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte Sprachkenntnisse"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250128_w156_2301381_1_00","publishedDate":1740700800000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2301381-1","citation":"W156 2301381-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250128_w156_2301381_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250128_w156_2301381_1_00","value":"W156 2301381-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"NAG-DV","citation":"§ 9 NAG-DV","clauseId":"NOR40246949","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 9","id":"20004470.11","lawType":"V","normId":"20004470","value":"§ 9 NAG-DV"},{"abbreviation":"NAG-DV","citation":"NAG-DV","clauseId":"NOR40253942","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"20004470","lawType":"V","normId":"20004470","value":"NAG-DV "},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"NAG","citation":"NAG","clauseId":"NOR40205333","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"20004242","lawType":"BG","normId":"20004242","value":"NAG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"NAG","citation":"§ 21a NAG","clauseId":"NOR40205360","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 21a","id":"20004242.19","lawType":"BG","normId":"20004242","value":"§ 21a NAG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 6 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40245607","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.31.7","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 6 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbrNr":2,"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016955","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000309.6.0","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000309","value":"Art 6 Abs. 1 EMRK"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2301381-1/5E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra KREBITZ als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde der XXXX GmbH in 1010 Wien (Beschwerdeführerin), gegen d…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W156 2301381-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Der Mitbeteiligte weist eine abgeschlossene Ausbildung als Bachelor of Economics nach und ist somit die Ausbildung unter das Berufsbild „Sozial-, Wirtschaftswissenschafter/innen, wissenschaftliche Statistiker"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Der Mitbeteiligte weist eine abgeschlossene Ausbildung als Bachelor of Economics nach und ist somit die Ausbildung unter das Berufsbild „Sozial-, Wirtschaftswissenschafter/innen, wissenschaftliche Statistiker"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.3333333432674408},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0},"vector_distance":0.8405514359474182}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20241018_w167_2297804_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2297804-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1731369600000,"citation":"W167 2297804-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1729209600000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20241018_w167_2297804_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20241018_w167_2297804_1_00","publishedDate":1731369600000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2297804-1","citation":"W167 2297804-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20241018_w167_2297804_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20241018_w167_2297804_1_00","value":"W167 2297804-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W167 2297804-1/6E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela ECKERSDORFER und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Beschwerde von XXXX (BF…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2297804-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Wie schon von der belangten"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Wie schon von der belangten"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.3125},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0},"vector_distance":0.85603266954422}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20251028_w167_2311824_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2311824-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1766361600000,"citation":"W167 2311824-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1761609600000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20251028_w167_2311824_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20251028_w167_2311824_1_00","publishedDate":1766361600000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2311824-1","citation":"W167 2311824-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20251028_w167_2311824_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20251028_w167_2311824_1_00","value":"W167 2311824-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.187.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40272197","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.32.1.0.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"}],"snippet":" W167 2311824-1/11E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und durch die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela DINHOBL und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK über die Beschwerde von XXXX (beschwerdeführende …","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2311824-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Die gegenständlich nachgewiesene Ausbildung dauerte jedoch nur 18 Monate, weshalb sie"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Die gegenständlich nachgewiesene Ausbildung dauerte jedoch nur 18 Monate, weshalb sie"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20251007_w167_2308772_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2308772-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1763424000000,"citation":"W167 2308772-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1759795200000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20251007_w167_2308772_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Lehrabschluss Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte Vergleichbarkeitsbetrachtung"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20251007_w167_2308772_1_00","publishedDate":1763424000000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2308772-1","citation":"W167 2308772-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20251007_w167_2308772_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20251007_w167_2308772_1_00","value":"W167 2308772-1"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.187.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40252041","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 1","id":"10008365.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"}],"snippet":" W167 2308772-1/10E W167 2308775-1/10E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag.a Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela DINHOBL und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Beschwer…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2308772-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 2.4. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Es ist zu prüfen, ob"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 2.4. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Es ist zu prüfen, ob"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250918_w167_2304813_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304813-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1761868800000,"citation":"W167 2304813-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1758153600000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250918_w167_2304813_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250918_w167_2304813_1_00","publishedDate":1761868800000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304813-1","citation":"W167 2304813-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250918_w167_2304813_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250918_w167_2304813_1_00","value":"W167 2304813-1"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.187.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"}],"snippet":" W167 2304813-1/5E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag.a Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela DINHOBL und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Beschwerde von XXXX (beschw…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2304813-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 2.4. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Es ist zu prüfen, ob"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 2.4. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Es ist zu prüfen, ob"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304588-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1756339200000,"citation":"W167 2304588-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1751846400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Punktevergabe Qualifikation Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","publishedDate":1756339200000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304588-1","citation":"W167 2304588-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","value":"W167 2304588-1"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304591-1","citation":"W167 2304591-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","value":"W167 2304591-1"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l02","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l01","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2022140322_20230419l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2022140322_20230419l00","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W167 2304588-1/5E W167 2304591-1/5E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag.a Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela ECKERSDORFER und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Besch…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2304588-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Der BF verfügt unstrittig über"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Der BF verfügt unstrittig über"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304591-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1756339200000,"citation":"W167 2304591-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1751846400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Punktevergabe Qualifikation Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","publishedDate":1756339200000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304588-1","citation":"W167 2304588-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304588_1_00","value":"W167 2304588-1"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2304591-1","citation":"W167 2304591-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250707_w167_2304591_1_00","value":"W167 2304591-1"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l02","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022140322_20230419l01","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/14/0322","citation":"Ra 2022/14/0322","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2022140322_20230419l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2022140322_20230419l00","value":"Ra 2022/14/0322"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W167 2304588-1/5E W167 2304591-1/5E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag.a Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela ECKERSDORFER und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Besch…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2304591-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Der BF verfügt unstrittig über"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) 3.3. Für den Beschwerdefall bedeutet das: Der BF verfügt unstrittig über"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250630_w167_2309852_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2309852-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1755475200000,"citation":"W167 2309852-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1751241600000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250630_w167_2309852_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250630_w167_2309852_1_00","publishedDate":1755475200000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W167 2309852-1","citation":"W167 2309852-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250630_w167_2309852_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250630_w167_2309852_1_00","value":"W167 2309852-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/09/0014","citation":"Ra 2024/09/0014","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024090014_20240513l00","value":"Ra 2024/09/0014"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090027_20220315l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0027","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090027_20220315l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"BAG","citation":"BAG","clauseId":"NOR30006524","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10006276","lawType":"BG","normId":"10006276","value":"BAG"},{"abbreviation":"BAG","citation":"§ 6 Abs. 1 BAG","clauseId":"NOR40118820","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 6","id":"10006276.9.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10006276","value":"§ 6 Abs. 1 BAG"},{"abbreviation":"BAG","citation":"§ 6 Abs. 6 BAG","clauseId":"NOR40118820","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 6","id":"10006276.9.6","lawType":"BG","normId":"10006276","value":"§ 6 Abs. 6 BAG"},{"abbreviation":"BAG","citation":"§ 5 Abs. 1 BAG","clauseId":"NOR40073554","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 5","id":"10006276.8.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10006276","value":"§ 5 Abs. 1 lit c BAG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W167 2309852-1/11E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Daria MACA-DAASE als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichterin Mag. Manuela DINHOBL und den fachkundigen Laienrichter Mag. Johannes DENK als Beisitzer/in über die Beschwerde XXXX StA. Kosovo…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W167 2309852-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Gemäß § 5 Abs. 1 lit. c des Berufsausbildungsgesetzes, BGBl. Nr"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwSlg. 18558 A). Die abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung in einem Mangelberuf muss einem Lehrabschluss aber nur vergleichbar sein (vgl. VwGH 15.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0027; VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046; siehe auch ErläutRV 1077 BlgNR 24 GP, 12). (VwGH 13.05.2024, Ra 2024/09/0014) Gemäß § 5 Abs. 1 lit. c des Berufsausbildungsgesetzes, BGBl. Nr"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306422_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2306422-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1752451200000,"citation":"W156 2306422-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1747094400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306422_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306422_1_00","publishedDate":1752451200000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2306422-1","citation":"W156 2306422-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306422_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306422_1_00","value":"W156 2306422-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs.1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016961","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000793.6.0","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000793","value":"Art 6 Abs. 1 EMRK"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2306422-1/6E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra KREBITZ als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde der XXXX , vertreten durch Mag. Ferdinand Attems, Rechtsa…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W156 2306422-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). In seinem Erkenntnis vom 01.09.2022, Zl. Ra 2021/09/0260, hat der Verwaltungsgerichtshof festgehalten, dass im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). In seinem Erkenntnis vom 01.09.2022, Zl. Ra 2021/09/0260, hat der Verwaltungsgerichtshof festgehalten, dass im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250513_w156_2304575_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2304575-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1752451200000,"citation":"W156 2304575-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1747094400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2304575_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2304575_1_00","publishedDate":1752451200000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2304575-1","citation":"W156 2304575-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2304575_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2304575_1_00","value":"W156 2304575-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs.1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016961","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000793.6.0","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000793","value":"Art 6 Abs. 1 EMRK"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2304575-1/11E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra KREBITZ als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde des XXXX , StA. Volksrepublik China, vertreten durch Rech…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W156 2304575-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Wie bereits beweiswürdigend festgestellt wurde, konnte mit dem im Verfahren vorgelegten Ausbildungsunterlagen keine einschlägige abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung, die mit der österreichischen Lehre „Koch/Köchin“"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). Wie bereits beweiswürdigend festgestellt wurde, konnte mit dem im Verfahren vorgelegten Ausbildungsunterlagen keine einschlägige abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung, die mit der österreichischen Lehre „Koch/Köchin“"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306582_1_00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2306582-1","apiPath":["Bvwg"],"changedDate":1752192000000,"citation":"W156 2306582-1","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1747094400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306582_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Berufsausbildung Fachkräfteverordnung Nachweismangel Punktevergabe Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306582_1_00","publishedDate":1752192000000,"refs":[{"Geschaeftszahl":"W156 2306582-1","citation":"W156 2306582-1","documentType":"decision","id":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306582_1_00","institution":["BVwG"],"normId":"bvwgt_20250513_w156_2306582_1_00","value":"W156 2306582-1"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"B-VG","citation":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG","clauseId":"NOR40201324","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 133","id":"10000138.186.5","lawType":"BVG","normId":"10000138","value":"Art. 133 Abs. 4 B-VG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l03","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l02","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0260","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0260","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021090260_20220901l01","value":"Ra 2021/09/0260"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs.1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 1 VwGVG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGVG","citation":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG","clauseId":"NOR40196848","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 24","id":"20008255.25.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"20008255","value":"§ 24 Abs. 4 VwGVG"},{"abbrNr":4,"abbreviation":"EMRK","citation":"Art. 6 Abs. 1 EMRK","clauseId":"NOR12016961","documentType":"law","enumeration":"Art. 6","id":"10000793.6.0","lawType":"Vertrag","normId":"10000793","value":"Art 6 Abs. 1 EMRK"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080027_20190221l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0027","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0027","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080027_20190221l01","value":"Ra 2019/08/0027"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":" W156 2306582-1/14E IM NAMEN DER REPUBLIK! Das Bundesverwaltungsgericht hat durch die Richterin Mag. Alexandra KREBITZ als Vorsitzende und die fachkundige Laienrichter Dr. Johannes Pflug und Alexander Wirth als Beisitzer über die Beschwerde der XXXX GmbH, vertreten durch Mag. Ferdinand Attems, R…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"W156 2306582-1"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). In seinem Erkenntnis vom 01.09.2022, Zl. Ra 2021/09/0260, hat der Verwaltungsgerichtshof festgehalten, dass im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"hat als Mindestanforderung für eine abgeschlossene Berufsausbildung einen österreichischen Lehrabschluss oder eine vergleichbare Ausbildung vorgesehen (vgl. VwGH 25.01.2013, 2012/09/0068; vergleiche auch VwGH 26.02.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046). In seinem Erkenntnis vom 01.09.2022, Zl. Ra 2021/09/0260, hat der Verwaltungsgerichtshof festgehalten, dass im Zusammenhang mit der Ausbildungsdauer die Ausbildung einer Lehrausbildung nur"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.25},"text_match":2314894167592927000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510927360","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":1,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167592927321","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["jwt_2025090055_20251020l00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/09/0055","apiPath":["Vwgh"],"changedDate":1767830400000,"citation":"Ra 2025/09/0055","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1760918400000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"jwt_2025090055_20251020l00","institution":["VwGH"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":["Auslegung Anwendung der Auslegungsmethoden Verhältnis der wörtlichen Auslegung zur teleologischen und historischen Auslegung Bedeutung der Gesetzesmaterialien VwRallg3/2/2 Begründungspflicht Beweiswürdigung und Beweismittel Allgemein Begründungspflicht Beweiswürdigung und Beweismittel Behandlung von Parteieinwendungen Ablehnung von Beweisanträgen Abstandnahme von Beweisen Sachverhalt Sachverhaltsfeststellung Beweismittel Sachverhalt Sachverhaltsfeststellung Parteivorbringen Erforschung des Parteiwillens"],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"jwt_2025090055_20251020l00","publishedDate":1764028800000,"refs":[{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR11008515","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10008365","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40272197","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.32.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40257948","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12a","id":"10008365.16.1.0.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 12a Abs. 1 Z 1 AuslBG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 12 Abs. 1 Z 2 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40228866","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12","id":"10000795.12.1.1.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 12 Abs. 1 Z 2 VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"AuslBG","citation":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG","clauseId":"NOR40272197","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 20d","id":"10008365.32.1.0.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10008365","value":"§ 20d Abs. 1 Z 2 AuslBG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l03","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090059_20220322l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l01","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020090046_20210226l02","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/09/0046","citation":"Ra 2020/09/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020090046_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0036","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0036","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2019080036_20190605l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2019080036_20190605l00","value":"Ra 2019/08/0036"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0036","Rechtssatznummer":"5","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0036","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080036_20190605l05","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080036_20190605l05","value":"Ra 2019/08/0036"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2019/08/0036","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ra 2019/08/0036","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2019080036_20190605l04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2019080036_20190605l04","value":"Ra 2019/08/0036"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/08/0090","citation":"Ra 2017/08/0090","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2017080090_20181002l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2017080090_20181002l00","value":"Ra 2017/08/0090"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/08/0124","citation":"Ra 2017/08/0124","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2017080124_20171211l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2017080124_20171211l00","value":"Ra 2017/08/0124"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/08/0124","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2017/08/0124","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2017080124_20171211l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2017080124_20171211l01","value":"Ra 2017/08/0124"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/08/0124","citation":"Ra 2017/08/0124","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2017080124_20180411l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2017080124_20180411l00","value":"Ra 2017/08/0124"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/11/0098","Rechtssatznummer":"5","citation":"Ra 2023/11/0098","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l05","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l05","value":"Ra 2023/11/0098"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/11/0098","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ra 2023/11/0098","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l04","value":"Ra 2023/11/0098"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/11/0098","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2023/11/0098","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023110098_20241217l02","value":"Ra 2023/11/0098"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0099","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0099","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022090099_20221207l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022090099_20221207l02","value":"Ra 2022/09/0099"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0099","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0099","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022090099_20221207l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022090099_20221207l01","value":"Ra 2022/09/0099"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0099","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0099","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2022090099_20221207l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2022090099_20221207l00","value":"Ra 2022/09/0099"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/09/0024","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2023/09/0024","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l03","value":"Ra 2023/09/0024"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/09/0024","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2023/09/0024","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l02","value":"Ra 2023/09/0024"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/09/0024","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2023/09/0024","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023090024_20230316l01","value":"Ra 2023/09/0024"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 42 Abs. 2 Z 3 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40148077","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 42","id":"10000795.48.2.0.2","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 42 Abs. 2 Z 3 lit. b und c VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 47 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254656","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 47","id":"10000795.54","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§§ 47 ff VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 53 Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40148089","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 53","id":"10000795.60.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 53 Abs. 1 VwGG"}],"snippet":"Der Verwaltungsgerichtshof hat durch den Vorsitzenden Senatspräsident Dr. Doblinger, Hofrat Mag. Feiel sowie Hofrätin Dr. Koprivnikar als Richter, unter Mitwirkung der Schriftführerin Mag. a Rieder, über die außerordentliche Revision 1. der A B und 2. des C D, beide vertreten durch Mag. Robert Bitsc…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"Ra 2025/09/0055"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"Österreich entspricht (vgl. VwGH 22.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0059, mit Verweis auf VwGH 25.1.2013, 2012/09/0068, und VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046), wobei ergänzend darauf hinzuweisen ist, dass vor dem Hintergrund des § 34a Abs. 1 Berufsausbildungsgesetz, wonach (u.a.) für den Bereich"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","09","0046"],"snippet":"Österreich entspricht (vgl. VwGH 22.3.2022, Ra 2020/09/0059, mit Verweis auf VwGH 25.1.2013, 2012/09/0068, und VwGH 26.2.2021, Ra 2020/09/0046), wobei ergänzend darauf hinzuweisen ist, dass vor dem Hintergrund des § 34a Abs. 1 Berufsausbildungsgesetz, wonach (u.a.) für den Bereich"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.1875},"text_match":2314894167458709500,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"4419510861824","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2314894167458709594","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["jwt_2025020052_20250415l00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/02/0052","apiPath":["Vwgh"],"changedDate":1747612800000,"citation":"Ra 2025/02/0052","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1744675200000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"jwt_2025020052_20250415l00","institution":["VwGH"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":[],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"jwt_2025020052_20250415l00","publishedDate":1747612800000,"refs":[{"abbreviation":"PBStV","citation":"PBStV","clauseId":"NOR40200965","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10012794","lawType":"V","normId":"10012794","value":"PBStV"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 34 Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40228871","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 34","id":"10000795.37.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 34 Abs. 1 VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 34 Abs. 1a VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40228871","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 34","id":"10000795.37.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 34 Abs. 1a VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 28 Abs. 3 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40196853","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 28","id":"10000795.28.3","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 28 Abs. 3 VwGG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/02/0010","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2024/02/0010","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2024020010_20250310l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2024020010_20250310l01","value":"Ra 2024/02/0010"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/02/0010","citation":"Ra 2024/02/0010","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024020010_20250310l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024020010_20250310l00","value":"Ra 2024/02/0010"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2015/06/0128","citation":"Ra 2015/06/0128","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2015060128_20160129l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2015060128_20160129l00","value":"Ra 2015/06/0128"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2015/06/0128","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2015/06/0128","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2015060128_20160129l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2015060128_20160129l01","value":"Ra 2015/06/0128"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2016/02/0062","citation":"Ra 2016/02/0062","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2016020062_20160419l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2016020062_20160419l00","value":"Ra 2016/02/0062"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2016/02/0062","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2016/02/0062","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2016020062_20160419l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2016020062_20160419l01","value":"Ra 2016/02/0062"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/05/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2023/05/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023050046_20230406l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023050046_20230406l02","value":"Ra 2023/05/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/05/0046","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2023/05/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2023050046_20230406l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2023050046_20230406l01","value":"Ra 2023/05/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/05/0046","citation":"Ra 2023/05/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2023050046_20230406l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2023050046_20230406l00","value":"Ra 2023/05/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/09/0007","citation":"Ra 2021/09/0007","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2021090007_20210226l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2021090007_20210226l00","value":"Ra 2021/09/0007"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/12/0088","citation":"Ra 2017/12/0088","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2017120088_20181003l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2017120088_20181003l00","value":"Ra 2017/12/0088"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/12/0088","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2017/12/0088","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2017120088_20181003l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2017120088_20181003l03","value":"Ra 2017/12/0088"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2017/12/0088","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2017/12/0088","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2017120088_20181003l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2017120088_20181003l02","value":"Ra 2017/12/0088"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2014/03/0045","citation":"Ra 2014/03/0045","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2014030045_20150218l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2014030045_20150218l00","value":"Ra 2014/03/0045"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2014/03/0045","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2014/03/0045","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2014030045_20150218l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2014030045_20150218l03","value":"Ra 2014/03/0045"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2014/03/0045","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ra 2014/03/0045","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2014030045_20150218l04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2014030045_20150218l04","value":"Ra 2014/03/0045"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/02/0013","Rechtssatznummer":"5","citation":"Ra 2020/02/0013","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l05","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l05","value":"Ra 2020/02/0013"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/02/0013","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/02/0013","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l01","value":"Ra 2020/02/0013"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/02/0013","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2020/02/0013","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020020013_20200304l03","value":"Ra 2020/02/0013"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/02/0003","citation":"Ra 2024/02/0003","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024020003_20240125l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024020003_20240125l00","value":"Ra 2024/02/0003"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/02/0003","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ra 2024/02/0003","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2024020003_20240125l04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2024020003_20240125l04","value":"Ra 2024/02/0003"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/02/0003","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2024/02/0003","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2024020003_20240125l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2024020003_20240125l03","value":"Ra 2024/02/0003"}],"snippet":"Der Verwaltungsgerichtshof hat durch den Vorsitzenden Senatspräsident Mag. Nedwed als Richter sowie die Hofrätinnen Mag. Dr. Maurer Kober und Mag. Schindler als Richterinnen, unter Mitwirkung der Schriftführerin Mag. a Andrés, über die Revision des R in S, vertreten durch die Schärmer + Partner Rec…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"Ra 2025/02/0052"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwGH 29.1.2016, Ra 2015/06/0128, VwGH 19.4.2016, Ra 2016/02/0062, mwN, VwGH 6.4.2023, Ra 2023/05/0046, mwN; insbesondere VwGH 26.2.2012, Ra 2021/09/0007). 8 Die gegenständliche Revision enthält unter dem Punkt II.3. „Zum Vorliegen einer Rechtsfrage grundsätzlicher Bedeutung“ zunächst im Wesentlichen nur"}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["0046","Ra","09"],"snippet":"VwGH 29.1.2016, Ra 2015/06/0128, VwGH 19.4.2016, Ra 2016/02/0062, mwN, VwGH 6.4.2023, Ra 2023/05/0046, mwN; insbesondere VwGH 26.2.2012, Ra 2021/09/0007). 8 Die gegenständliche Revision enthält unter dem Punkt II.3. „Zum Vorliegen einer Rechtsfrage grundsätzlicher Bedeutung“ zunächst im Wesentlichen nur"}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.15000000596046448},"text_match":2312642366839718000,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"3319998840832","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2312642366839717978","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]},{"found":1,"group_key":["jwt_2025110069_20250606l00"],"hits":[{"document":{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/11/0069","apiPath":["Vwgh"],"changedDate":1753315200000,"citation":"Ra 2025/11/0069","contentType":"head","decisionDate":1749168000000,"documentType":"decision","hasSummary":false,"id":"jwt_2025110069_20250606l00","institution":["VwGH"],"institutionType":"Gericht","keywords":[],"legalCategories":[],"normId":"jwt_2025110069_20250606l00","publishedDate":1751932800000,"refs":[{"abbreviation":"TNRSG","citation":"TNRSG","clauseId":"NOR40181126","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 0","id":"10010907","lawType":"BG","normId":"10010907","value":"TNRSG "},{"abbreviation":"TNRSG","citation":"§ 14 Abs. 4 TNRSG","clauseId":"NOR40200909","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 14","id":"10010907.34.4","lawType":"BG","normId":"10010907","value":"§ 14 Abs. 4 TNRSG"},{"abbreviation":"VStG","citation":"§ 64 Abs. 2 VStG","clauseId":"NOR40205672","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 64","id":"10005770.82.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10005770","value":"§ 64 Abs. 2 VStG"},{"abbreviation":"TNRSG","citation":"§ 12 Abs. 2 TNRSG","clauseId":"NOR40216550","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12","id":"10010907.30.2","lawType":"BG","normId":"10010907","value":"§ 12 Abs. 2 TNRSG"},{"abbreviation":"TNRSG","citation":"§ 12 Abs. 1 Z 4 TNRSG","clauseId":"NOR40216550","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 12","id":"10010907.30.1.0.3","lawType":"BG","normId":"10010907","value":"§ 12 Abs. 1 Z 4 TNRSG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ro 2022/11/0019","Rechtssatznummer":"6","citation":"Ro 2022/11/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j06","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j06","value":"Ro 2022/11/0019"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ro 2022/11/0019","Rechtssatznummer":"5","citation":"Ro 2022/11/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j05","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j05","value":"Ro 2022/11/0019"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ro 2022/11/0019","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ro 2022/11/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022110019_20230629j04","value":"Ro 2022/11/0019"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/11/0083","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2021/11/0083","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021110083_20230918l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021110083_20230918l02","value":"Ra 2021/11/0083"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/11/0083","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2021/11/0083","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2021110083_20230918l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2021110083_20230918l01","value":"Ra 2021/11/0083"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2021/11/0083","citation":"Ra 2021/11/0083","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2021110083_20230918l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2021110083_20230918l00","value":"Ra 2021/11/0083"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 34 Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40228871","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 34","id":"10000795.37.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 34 Abs. 1 VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 34 Abs. 1a VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40228871","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 34","id":"10000795.37.1","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 34 Abs. 1a VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40254651","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 25a","id":"10000795.26.0","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 25a Abs. 1 VwGG"},{"abbreviation":"VwGG","citation":"§ 28 Abs. 3 VwGG","clauseId":"NOR40196853","documentType":"law","enumeration":"§ 28","id":"10000795.28.3","lawType":"BG","normId":"10000795","value":"§ 28 Abs. 3 VwGG"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2024/11/0046","citation":"Ra 2024/11/0046","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2024110046_20241001l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2024110046_20241001l00","value":"Ra 2024/11/0046"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/11/0059","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2020/11/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2020110059_20200727l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2020110059_20200727l01","value":"Ra 2020/11/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2020/11/0059","citation":"Ra 2020/11/0059","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2020110059_20200727l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2020110059_20200727l00","value":"Ra 2020/11/0059"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/11/0047","citation":"Ra 2023/11/0047","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2023110047_20230328l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2023110047_20230328l00","value":"Ra 2023/11/0047"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2023/11/0047","citation":"Ra 2023/11/0047","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2023110047_20240115l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2023110047_20240115l00","value":"Ra 2023/11/0047"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0131","Rechtssatznummer":"4","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0131","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l04","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l04","value":"Ra 2022/09/0131"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0131","Rechtssatznummer":"3","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0131","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l03","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l03","value":"Ra 2022/09/0131"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2022/09/0131","Rechtssatznummer":"2","citation":"Ra 2022/09/0131","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l02","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2022090131_20231002l02","value":"Ra 2022/09/0131"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/02/0019","Rechtssatznummer":"1","citation":"Ra 2025/02/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwr_2025020019_20250228l01","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwr_2025020019_20250228l01","value":"Ra 2025/02/0019"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/02/0019","citation":"Ra 2025/02/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2025020019_20250228l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2025020019_20250228l00","value":"Ra 2025/02/0019"},{"Geschaeftszahl":"Ra 2025/02/0019","citation":"Ra 2025/02/0019","documentType":"decision","id":"jwt_2025020019_20250130l00","institution":["VwGH"],"normId":"jwt_2025020019_20250130l00","value":"Ra 2025/02/0019"}],"snippet":"Der Verwaltungsgerichtshof hat durch den Vorsitzenden Senatspräsident Mag. Samm sowie die Hofrätinnen MMag. Ginthör und Dr. Kronegger als Richterinnen und Richter, unter Mitwirkung der Schriftführerin Mag. a Janitsch, über die Revision des A K in W, vertreten durch die Neumayer Walter Rechtsanwälte…","source":"ris","caseNumber":"Ra 2025/11/0069"},"highlight":{"content":{"matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","Ra","Ra"],"snippet":"Vorliegen das Verwaltungsgericht fallbezogen, ohne dass diesbezüglich eine Abweichung von der Rechtsprechung des Verwaltungsgerichtshofes ersichtlich wäre, verneinte (siehe in diesem Zusammenhang etwa VwGH 27.7.2020, Ra 2020/11/0059, betreffend die bloße Erteilung von Weisungen; VwGH 15.1.2024, Ra 2023/11/0047; vgl. etwa auch VwGH 2.10.2023, Ra "}},"highlights":[{"field":"content","matched_tokens":["Ra","2020","Ra","Ra"],"snippet":"Vorliegen das Verwaltungsgericht fallbezogen, ohne dass diesbezüglich eine Abweichung von der Rechtsprechung des Verwaltungsgerichtshofes ersichtlich wäre, verneinte (siehe in diesem Zusammenhang etwa VwGH 27.7.2020, Ra 2020/11/0059, betreffend die bloße Erteilung von Weisungen; VwGH 15.1.2024, Ra 2023/11/0047; vgl. etwa auch VwGH 2.10.2023, Ra "}],"hybrid_search_info":{"rank_fusion_score":0.125},"text_match":2310390568099774500,"text_match_info":{"best_field_score":"2220487737344","best_field_weight":11,"fields_matched":2,"num_tokens_dropped":0,"score":"2310390568099774554","tokens_matched":4,"typo_prefix_score":0}}]}],"out_of":1753017,"page":1,"request_params":{"collection_name":"documents","first_q":"Ra 2020/09/0046","per_page":40,"q":"Ra 2020/09/0046"},"search_cutoff":false,"search_time_ms":4389}

Rechtssatz

Rückverweise

Rechtssatz

Rückverweise

Abweisung der Beschwerde gegen die Ablehnung der Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte für eine vietnamesische Fachkraft im Mangelberuf Koch—BVwG Entscheidung

Abweisung der Beschwerde gegen die Ablehnung einer Rot-Weiß-Rot-Karte für Fachkräfte in Mangelberufen—BVwG Entscheidung

Ra 2025/09/0055—VwGH Rechtssatz

W167 2293590-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W156 2301381-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2297804-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2311824-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2308772-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2304813-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2304588-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2304591-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W167 2309852-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W156 2306422-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W156 2304575-1—BVwG Entscheidung

W156 2306582-1—BVwG Entscheidung

Ra 2025/09/0055—VwGH Entscheidung

Ra 2025/02/0052—VwGH Entscheidung

Ra 2025/11/0069—VwGH Entscheidung